Skip to content
Up To Code

Manual 5 · Vendor Defense · 5.14 · Emergencies shelf

They charged you anyway.
How to fight the bill.

Passed final You — from the truck Takes: A letter tonight — the fight, weeks

Straight up front, because false hope wastes your time: some of these fights you win clean, some you win partway, and some you lose even doing everything right. One owner logged every callback to the second, landed zero of ten junk leads, and still got his refund refused. So this page isn't a promise. It's the actual machinery — the legal steps that give you the best shot, in the order that works, with the government's own rules behind each one. Build the paper as you go: the same folder feeds every front below, and it protects you even when the money doesn't come back.

Four fronts, and you may need more than one. Work them in this order:

  1. Read the statement and find what's really being charged.
  2. Dispute it with your card company the legal way.
  3. Shut off the payment if a vendor won't stop.
  4. File the complaints that actually move a company.

Front 1Read the statement (the card audit)

Before you fight a charge, find all of them, because the one that made you mad may not be the only one. The quiet damage is the charge that's been running for months while nobody read the statement. One office manager reconciling the company card found double and triple charges that had been running for fourteen months before anyone caught them. Another owner discovered he was being billed while his account was supposedly paused. A third was billed for six straight months against a service that was never delivered.

So pull the last twelve months of statements and go line by line. For every marketing or web charge, you need to be able to say what it's for and whether you're still getting it. Anything you can't explain, or thought you'd cancelled, or is billing while "paused" — flag it. That flagged list is what you fight.

Checkable result: twelve months of statements read, every marketing charge either explained or flagged, with the date and amount of each flagged one written down.

Front 2Dispute it with your card company (the legal way)

This is the strongest tool you have, and it's federal law — the Fair Credit Billing Act. It only covers credit cards and revolving charge accounts, not personal loans or vehicle loans. But if a marketing bill hit a credit card, this is your lever.

Now the catch, and it's aimed at you. Those billing-error rights are written for personal cards. A card opened for the business sits outside them, because the law exempts business-purpose credit. Send the letter anyway, and call your card company to ask what dispute rules apply to a business account — that answer comes from your bank, not from a statute. If the charge landed on a personal card, every right in this front is yours in full.

Paying by debit card or bank draft? This front's law is written for credit cards. Federal law still reaches your bank account: the CFPB's page says, as of July 2026, that you have the right to dispute and get your money back for unauthorized transfers from your account "as long as you tell your bank in time." That page does not print the deadline. So call your bank fast, bring the same paper trail, and ask them what your window is. On a bank account, Front 3 is your strongest move: kill the authorization at the source.

What you're allowed to dispute. Charges you never authorized (and your liability for an unauthorized charge is capped by law at $50), charges with the wrong amount or date or a math error, and charges for things you didn't accept or that weren't delivered as agreed. A cancelled service that kept billing, a charge for leads never sent — those fit.

The one detail people get wrong. You have to do it in writing, and the letter goes to the address the card company lists for billing inquiries — not the address you send payments to. They can be different addresses, printed in different corners of the statement. A dispute mailed to the payment address can be treated as if it never arrived. Your letter needs your name, address, account number, and a plain description of the mistake.

The clock, and it's a hard one. Your letter has to reach the card company within 60 days after the first bill that showed the error was sent to you. Miss that window and you lose the legal protection, so this is not a "get to it eventually" job. Call the card company right away too — but the call doesn't preserve your rights; the letter does. Send it so you can prove it arrived: certified mail with a return receipt — that's the version the law describes and nobody can argue with. (Never sent certified mail? Ask at the post-office counter for "certified, with a return receipt." They do the rest.) The card's secure-message system leaves a timestamp too, but the mailed letter to the billing-inquiries address is the one that locks in the rights — when the money is real, make the trip.

Already past the 60 days? Don't fold yet — this is the spot where owners who found the charges late give up early. The 60-day clock is the letter-rights clock. Call the card company anyway, say the word "dispute," and ask exactly what window applies to your charge. You may have lost the legal armor, not the fight.

What has to happen after you send it. The card company must acknowledge your dispute in writing within 30 days, and must resolve it within 90 days. While it investigates, you're allowed to withhold payment on the disputed amount and its finance charges — but you must keep paying the rest of the bill. And during the investigation the company cannot make you pay the disputed charge, cannot charge interest on it, and cannot report your payment as late to the credit bureaus if you paid the undisputed part on time. On a personal card, those are your protections — hold them to it.

Those dates only work if somebody is watching them. The day you mail the letter, put day 30 and day 90 on the calendar. If day 30 passes with nothing in writing, call the card company, give them the certified-mail tracking number, and ask for your dispute case number. Write it down. If day 90 passes with no resolution, name that missed deadline in the CFPB complaint in Front 4. A denial is an answer you can work with; silence isn't.

Build your dispute letter

Fill these in and the page writes the letter for you, in the form the law expects. Nothing you type here goes anywhere — the letter is built in your browser for you to copy, print, and mail. Send it to the billing-inquiries address on your statement, by certified mail. The typing can be whoever runs your screens; the signature and the mailbox are yours. (No printer, no helper? The letter's ingredients are all listed — a handwritten version with the same pieces counts just the same.)

One fair warning before you pick a reason. Merchants answer "I cancelled before this charge" with the signed contract and its notice clause. If that's your reason, attach your written cancellation proof (the dated email from leaving clean) so your paper meets theirs.

Front 3Shut off the payment (when a vendor won't stop)

Sometimes the vendor keeps pulling money after you've cancelled, and the dispute is fighting last month's charge while next month's is already scheduled. When that happens, you turn off the tap at the bank. One owner had money leave his account by automatic bank withdrawal a full month after cancelling. Another spent five months trying to get a vendor to stop and only ended it by cancelling the credit card the charges rode on. Killing the payment instrument — cancelling the card or revoking the automatic bank draft — is the real off-switch when a vendor won't honor a cancellation.

Two honest warnings before you do it. First, tell your bank it's an unauthorized recurring charge you've revoked, not just "cancel my card," so they block re-bills instead of reissuing a card the vendor can charge again. Second, expect pushback: one owner who cancelled his debit card got threatened with a lawsuit. Whether a given vendor means it is not something anyone can tell you from a web page. A threat costs nothing to send, and it lands hardest on the owner with no paper. So don't answer it hot and don't answer it on the phone. Save it exactly as it came in, with the date, into the same folder as everything else — that folder is Front 4.

When it doesn't take. A charge that lands again is not proof you did it wrong. The CFPB is blunt on two points: cancelling an automatic payment does not cancel what you owe — the contract has to be killed too — and it calls any payment the company starts after you've pulled permission an error to take back to your bank. So put your next billing date on the calendar and read that statement for the same amount under a new name. If it landed, call the bank, give them the date you revoked, and use the word "unauthorized."

Checkable result: the recurring authorization is revoked with your bank in writing, you've saved the confirmation, and your next billing date is on the calendar to re-check.

Front 4Collections, and the complaints that actually move

If it went to collections. It can arrive with no warning — one owner had $1,500 sent to collections without being told, another had roughly $600 for an un-taken lead put on a brand-new business's file. There are federal rights here under the debt-collection rule, and one limit on them: the rule covers debts for personal, family, or household purposes. A marketing bill for the business is a business debt, and the rule doesn't reach it. Send the letter below either way — on a personal debt it's your legal lever, on a business debt it's a documented record.

Here's the machinery. A collector must send you "validation information" about the debt, either as its first contact or within five days of it, by mail or electronically. That notice has to itemize what you supposedly owe and give you an end date for a 30-day window to dispute it.

The move: dispute it in writing, in time. You have 30 days after getting that validation information to dispute the debt in writing. And here's the lever — if you send a written dispute or a request for verification within that 30-day window, the collector must pause collecting the disputed amount until it adequately responds. On a personal debt, that letter legally stops the clock. Either way: send it certified, keep the receipt.

Where to complain so it counts. An angry phone call to the vendor goes nowhere. These three do something:

  • The CFPB complaint portal (consumerfinance.gov/complaint) is the one with teeth for anything involving a card company, a bank, or a debt collector: it forwards your complaint to the company, emails you updates, and lets you check the status. What it can't do is force an outcome: a company can answer and still tell you no, and an answer is not a refund. Fair warning: the portal is built for consumer complaints. File yours anyway, and if it bounces, your state attorney general is below. (Filling in the screen is a fine job for whoever runs your internet — the signature and the follow-up are yours.)
  • The FTC at ReportFraud.ftc.gov for the scam itself. Be clear-eyed: the FTC can't get your money back on an individual report — it says so plainly — but it uses the reports to build cases. File it for that, not for a refund.
  • Your state attorney general and state consumer-protection office (find yours through usa.gov/state-consumer). The state AG is the top legal officer in your state and handles complaints against businesses.

One place to spend less energy: the Better Business Bureau. It's fine to file a complaint there — but it's a private organization, not a regulator. Use it as a bonus, not your main shot. Your real leverage is the card dispute plus the offices above.

What winning and losing actually look like

Winning happens — one owner reported pushing back on an auto-renewed ad he'd already killed and settling the bill at 60 percent off. But the ceiling is real: the same paper trail that wins one fight loses another, and a card dispute can come back denied. If it does, the complaints above are pressure, not recovery. One recovery lever is left.

Small-claims court. For a charge in the hundreds-to-few-thousand range, small-claims court is built for a regular person with a folder of paper. The FTC's words: the costs are relatively low, the procedures are simple, and the dollar limits vary by state, with some states as high as $25,000 — then check with your local small claims court for how to file. Nobody can quote you your county's filing fee, your ceiling, or your forms from a web page. So spend twenty minutes before you spend the filing fee: call your county clerk's small-claims desk, get the fee and the limit, and ask what they do with a case against an out-of-state company. Ask what happens after a judgment while you have them — that's a separate question from winning one, and it's better asked before you file. Then read your contract for two words: arbitration and venue. Arbitration can block the courthouse; venue is where the contract says a dispute gets heard, and it isn't automatically your town. If either one shuts the door, the state-AG complaint above is your lane instead. Either way, the folder you built on Fronts 1 through 4 is the whole case.

Build the paper regardless of the odds, because paper is the only thing that travels from one front to the next.

Print this: the fight-the-bill sequence

Fighting the billin order

Fighting a charge is only half of it — if you haven't actually gotten out of the contract yet, do that cleanly first so new charges stop coming: leaving clean. And the reason a "month-to-month" deal is charging you a year's exit fee lives in the paperwork you signed — reading a proposal shows how to catch it next time.